I’ve posted several articles up on Amino Z in regards to The Biggest Loser Australia. Basically, I feel that it’s great to raise awareness for health, fitness & nutrition…but there are many (many) downfalls as to the training methods employed which could be quite dangerous.
You know what, I was reading a Network Blog (a fitness industry forum full of health and fitness professionals), where they were discussing exactly the same thing – the safety and effectiveness of this method of training.
There were 60 posts from professionals around the country, with all very similar opinions – it’s not safe, it’s not a good long-term solution and it’s geared toward entertainment, not the health and wellbeing of contestants. Many people felt that the way in which the contestants were treated was unacceptable also.
Here are some exerpts from what some industry professionals wrote:
“I feel that the trainers are unrealistically training the contestants.
If I was training morbidly obese individuals, I would not start with high intensity workouts – what trainer in their right mind would?!?!!? “
“It’s just not safe. Is that not one of our biggest concerns in the fitness industry?”
“Belittling people on television and encouraging backstabbing is not my idea of entertainment. Someone will die using the unsafe methods employed by these trainers. The show is complete bull and that is why I have only watched it twice and that was last week!
Never again.”
“Although it is great to see obese people exercising at an intense rate and losing weight, the show is too focused on WEIGHT ie kg lost. It would be much better and more educational for the general public to see body fat % decreasing rather than kg- any one can lose ‘weight’ just by cutting off an arm, or perhaps not drinking anything for 24 hrs. This focus also discourages muscle gain, as muscle weighs more than fat, but is more desirable since it is metabolically active.”
“The biggest loser has been both the best thing for the fitness industry and the worst, the best because it gets people thinking about the results they could get with a personal trainer and the worst because it depicts personal trainers in the worst possible way and the general public see us all that way.”
“What has always troubled me about the series is that it completely contrary to everything I was ever taught about weight loss ( slow weight loss is best) and training very overweight clients ( start slow etc) – I would never have asked an unfit 150kg client to jog!”
Catherine Chapman posted this excellent post:
“Whilst I am a regular viewer of the show I have to agree with many of the comments posted that yes, the training appears to be way too intense for participants of their size and fitness level. I also agree that there is not much thought given at all to technique. One particular episode really got to me – where 2 of the female contestants had to experience “Pain” and one was in a caged area “boxing” with a trainer whilst the other one was moving exremely heavy items on the outside of the caged area.
Having qualified with PunchFit in their punch pad course, kick pad course and personal trainer course, I was astounded to say the least to see how the “trainer” was using the focus pads to hit down on the punching mitts worn by the contestant who was boxing – also without any guidance as to how to “throw a punch”.
Its also interesting to note the number of past contestants who are now in advertisements for weight loss companies which provide meal substitute shakes, bars etc. Isn’t the whole idea of the show to teach them HOW to shop for, prepare and eat normal meals? Having said all of the above, I do feel it can be encouraging to others to lose weight and it is certainly amazing to see all the contestants when they reappear for the final show.”
Interested to hear your comments on the show!
Share on Facebook